The instructional strategy of “reinforcing effort” has the potential to make a considerable difference with student achievement. When students are able to make connections from their own data input and see the results it should have a greater impact on them. I think this is important because what we are really talking about it changing their perception or beliefs. The realization that they can actually have some control can be powerful encouragement to buy in. I teach in an inner city high school where 100% of students qualify for free or reduced meals. There is not much in their lives that students have power or control over. They often feel hopeless and that NOTHING they do matters. If we can use spread sheets to show them the effort they make can change the outcome, they may feel empowered. The only problem I see with this is that they may not be honest about how much effort they actually put toward their work. Or their perception of great effort may not be realistic.
I have had some experience with Brainpop.com (mentioned in chapter 10). My students like to do the quizzes after watching a short video on the site. They like the review quiz because it gives them immediate feedback on whether they have chosen correctly. I use a laptop and projector and we do the quiz as a group. Before we click on a choice we sometimes have lively debate and discussion on which choice is the correct response. The students are usually pretty engaged during these quizzes. The immediate reinforcement is there when they get the right answer. If they choose incorrectly they go back and choose again. This seems to me to be in line with the behaviorist theory.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

I think it is incredible that even high school students can be involved with a game and enjoy the immediate feedback! I have a son who is in high school, and he is very competitive and loves to debate. I can put him right in with the Brainpop situation. I don't usually think of activities in terms of learning theories, but this is a behaviorist based idea,for sure, but it works!
ReplyDeleteHi Molly, Bless your heart for teaching in the school that you do. There is a place in heaven for you.
ReplyDeleteI agree about students not being honest. We should be able to come up with some type of incentive to make them want to see the positive effects that this type of tracking has.
What would you think of having them teach you something and tracking in front of them? I am thinking of something like how to play the pokemon game or maybe you memorizing all of their birthdays. Just thinking out loud.
Robin Phares
Molly,
ReplyDeleteI teach elementary students, and I can see them trying to be honest on the effort chart, but I doubt they would be very accurate. They are just poor judges of how much time they are spending on any activity. I wonder what strategies we could use to increase your students' honesty on the chart and my students' accuracy? In your case, perhaps making it private for the students only might help, but then how do you ensure they do it! (Boy, am I gald you teach high school and I teach elementary!) In my case, I might suggest that the students' parents help them judge the time spent. This just might help.
Wow! I never thought of modeling my effort strategy. Great idea. I'll work on coming up with something they can teach me! Thanks for the idea...
ReplyDeleteLynne,
ReplyDeleteYes! They do get competitive. I also notice students who are not very confident will participate as part of a group and then be loud about being right!
Molly
Molly,
ReplyDeleteEmpowerment really is important to helping students overcome life's overwhelming problems. I was really engaged by the reinforcing effort section of Using Technology with Classroom Instruction that Works. Did you see the example about the teacher in charge of freshmen orientation? He collected anonymous effort data and success stories from honor students to share with incoming freshmen. Maybe this would work in your situation where some students "may not be honest about how much effort they actually put toward their work. Or their perception of great effort may not be realistic."
Molly,
ReplyDeleteI love your suggestion of using brain pop or something similar for immediate review and feedback. I think that my students would both enjoy this type of activity and they would benefit from it. Thank you for the suggestion. I look forward to trying it out.
~Rachel